Joey With the Mustache Has an URGE to Get Weird

  • Have you seen our newsletters? Sign up HERE

Courtesy of Joey With the Mustache.

When I first heard Joey With the Mustache play, I was instantly a fan, Do I remember every detail? Absolutely not. Do I remember how good it was? Absolutely. So when we got on the phone ahead of his Thanksgiving weekend set at URGE in Miami, we figured out which Fire Island friends we had in common and got right into the music. We talked about the party where he found his people, the record that got him an extra hour behind the decks in Miami, and what happens when you slip a little Broadway into a room full of house boys.

Before there was Joey With the Mustache, who was Joey? Because that is the most wonderfully specific DJ name.

There are a lot of Joeys in New York, and not just because of a guy on Friends. The mustache started growing in 2017, after a very fateful trip where I discovered electronic music. Before that, I’d done a lot of classical composition and jazz and arranging. But the name was really just a way for people to identify which Joey they were talking about.

MC I ask DJs this all the time: Where were you when you looked around a dance floor and went, “Okay, these are my people”? We’ve all had that moment, but you took it a step further and got behind the decks.

When I moved to New York in 2017, I didn’t have a ton of friends. I was relatively new to the scene, so I was getting my feet wet in different communities. One night, I went to a party thrown by a Burning Man camp. I showed up and there were all these very handsome, sweet men, and everyone was so thoughtful about each other’s experience. They went above and beyond in terms of taking care of each other. I was like, “Wait a second. This is so different from what I’ve experienced before.”

I’ve really taken those Burning Man principles to heart. You see people on a dance floor having a little heart-to-heart or handing something out, and you realize they’re thinking about the whole room. When everybody puts in 10 percent, you get it back tenfold. You get this whole sense of community celebrating together, and that can really move somebody’s spirit.

Was there a gig that took you from “Let me try this” to “Oh, this is what I do for a living now”?

I don’t think there was one pivotal moment. A long time ago, I didn’t even know this job existed. I never thought it was going to be the way I paid my bills. It just slowly started happening, and at some point I realized, “Oh, dear, I have to start dealing with the IRS.”

Once I started dealing with the business side, I had the sense that, okay, this is a career now. I still have days when I go in to work on music, four or five hours go by, and I’m like, “Wait a second. This is my actual job.” It’s crazy.

I just spent two weeks in Florida, and Miami is a whole different animal. You can go out in Brooklyn, Hell’s Kitchen, Fire Island, Asbury Park, and then you get down there and it’s a totally different vibe. Do you feel like you have to change it up for URGE?

Playing on Fire Island, I don’t really feel like I have to. I feel like people come to Fire Island and people come to URGE for the same reason. They want to celebrate with their community. And I’m excited to be part of such a diverse lineup. There are so many different ways for people to feel at home musically. I’m excited to hear what my friends on the lineup bring to the table and to get out there and dance with them, too.

One of the things I love about your sets is there’s disco, there’s house, and then there’s Broadway. The New York boys get it. Do you throw in a show tune in Miami and somebody goes, “What is this?” Or do they get it, too?

That’s a really good DJ question. I think of it like putting together a charcuterie board. There are meats and cheeses people know, and there are some they don’t. Maybe somebody at the table goes, “Oh, wait, I love this kind of Roquefort,” and somebody else is unsure, but then they try it with the wine pairing. Now you’ve elevated the experience because somebody got to share what they love.

That can happen on a dance floor, too. I think about how different people might enjoy the experience. Everybody can have their own way into it.

Give me a record you threw on thinking, “Let’s see if this works,” and it paid off.

I played a track called “Burn It Up” on the beach at Winter Party in Miami in March. It brought this really vibrant, jacked-up house energy I hadn’t heard on that dance floor yet. It was my first time playing that party, and there’d been hail earlier in the day. We were really trying to pick the energy back up, and people just went for it. They ended up extending my set by an hour.

An extra hour after hail in Miami? I love that. And now you’re going back for Thanksgiving weekend. Community comes up so much when you talk about what you do. Does playing over a holiday, when people are getting together with chosen family, add something for you?

Absolutely. I’ll be coming from Fire Island Pines, where I’ll be working on my house and spending time with my mom. I feel grateful every day that my family is so supportive, and I know how much my chosen family means to me, too.

Getting to create the soundtrack for those really special moments of community is a huge honor and something I take very seriously. And I have a lot of fun doing it. I’ve been seeing people on Instagram getting excited for URGE, and there’s so much creativity already. The outfits, the looks. I’m excited to meet those people.

Everybody has an opinion about what nightlife should be doing right now. What are you loving, and where do you think we could do a little better?

I love seeing people take risks. I’m seeing sober parties, daytime parties, coffee shop parties. People are trying different ways to connect. After the pandemic, we were so excited to be together that we could do it anywhere. For some people, that novelty has worn off, so as producers we have to double down on giving people a reason to come together.

And I want even more risk. I get the business side. You’re negotiating with vendors and the venue, you want everybody to get paid, and you want to keep the ticket affordable. You can still end up in the hole. But I’m hoping people continue to look inward and find their weird. There’s so much out there that looks and sounds like what’s already there. If we can find our spark and find what makes us queer, what makes us unique, I think we’ll be able to connect with more people.

I’m going to finish with this. Somebody comes to your set at URGE and walks off that beach. What’s the one thing you want them to leave with?

I hope somebody walks away thinking, “You know what? I’ve never heard that track before, and I absolutely love it.” It could’ve been produced in the ’80s or the ’90s. Getting to introduce somebody to a piece of music that scratches their itch and makes them feel seen is one of my absolute favorite things. I’m getting goosebumps just talking about it. And if they get to have that moment with their friends, they’ll have something to talk about for years to come.

Follow Joey With the Mustache on Instagram @joeywiththemustache

Tickets for URGE Miami Festival are available now at UrgeMiamiFestival.com.

OutSFL

Phone: 954-514-7095
Hours: Monday - Friday 9AM - 2PM
Editorial@OutSFL.com
Sales@OutSFL.com

Calendar@outsfl.com

Corrections: corrections@outsfl.com

PO Box 23817 • Oakland Park, FL 33307

Navigate

GOT A TIP?

Got a juicy lead or story idea? Let us know! You can also submit an anonymous news tip by clicking here.

GOT A TIP

   

Out South Florida

Help sustain independent LGBTQ journalism, community coverage, and local voices across South Florida.

donate button