Growth of a Foodie Town

  • Have you seen our newsletters? Sign up HERE

Dairy Queen. Photo courtesy of Wilton Manors Historical Society.

Although now known as a culinary destination, as well as the hub of LGBTQ life in South Florida, Wilton Manors wasn’t always that way. Founded in the early 1920s, the town was defined by family farms, quiet citrus groves, and a small-town commercial hub. The iconic Five Points intersection and early stretches of Wilton Drive featured everyday local staples such as Manor Market (2209 N. Manor Dr., now home to Eagle), small diners, and an A&W Drive-In (where the Wells Fargo Bank is now located).

In the 1950s and 1960s, as home air-conditioning became available, Wilton Manors started to grow into a real town. Grand Union grocery store opened in the Shoppes of Wilton Manors mall in 1958, later replaced by a Piggly-Wiggly. Dairy Queen, still located on the South End of Wilton Drive, opened in 1959.  

The old Manor Market was re-imagined as The Flame Restaurant, in 1959 by Manors Market’s owners Lamar Braddy and Frank Starling. It only lasted a year and was replaced by an imitation of The Playboy Club, The Playmate Club, which lasted until 1965. It was soon replaced by Back Door A-Go-Go, which catered to businessmen during the days, with lingerie shows. Later in the evening, the clientele switched and male go-go boys took to the stage. That arrangement lasted about a year. Then the venue tried blue grass music as a “Country Music Supper Club.” No surprise that didn’t succeed either.

In 1979 the venue switched formats again, and reopened as The Sir Nicholas Inn, a Polish/Eastern-European supper club. It was heavily advertised and became a popular tourist destination. Then, in 1986 the venue was subdivided, with the Sir Nicholas Inn in one section and the Tahiti Inn in the other (perhaps responding to the newly opened and popular Mai Kai in Fort Lauderdale.) Both ventures failed and they were combined into one business, by the original club’s co-owner, Dottie James. The Palms was one of the first to cater to the gay community, it offered a dining room, bar, and cabaret. It operated throughout the 1980s.

In 1990, Tony Dee a real estate developer and his lover/partner and Charlie Mielke, purchased the entire strip of buildings and transformed The Palms into Chardees. He brought headliners such as Jennifer Holliday, Eartha Kitt, and Judy Tenuta to perform at the supper club.  He sold the business in 2005 and Chardees closed in 2007. Since then, it has housed numerous bars, starting with Bill’s Filling Station  (best known for an early club appearance by the singer Stefani Germanotta, aka Lady Gaga), followed by a series of short-lived clubs until it became Eagle.

In the late 1990s and early 2000s, as Fort Lauderdale’s and Miami Beach’s traditionally LGBTQ neighborhoods became too expensive, a number of gay bars, restaurants and businesses began to open in Wilton Manors. Among them; Georgie’s Alibi, opened in 1997 by George Kessinger in the Shoppes of Wilton Manors. Although not the first LGBT bar in Wilton Manors Chardees and Palms preceded it, as well as The Other Side, a lesbian bar), Charlie’s is widely credited with permanently anchoring the modern gay strip, later evolving into Alibi Monkey Bar.

Gone but not forgotten; these are restaurants that were once a thriving part of Wilton Manors:

Lotus Chinese, after many years at 1432 E 26th St., the popular Chinese restaurant moved to Fort Lauderdale.

After a short stint as The Texan, a former A&P located in the Island City Plaza on 26th St. near Dixie Hwy., became Old Florida Seafood House. The landmark restaurant opened in 1977 and closed in 2013. After a brief stint as a BBQ joint, it became home to a thrift store. Island City Plaza was also home to Downey’s Donuts and a Kentucky Fried Chicken. Granny’s Ice Cream Shop was located on Andrews and 29th St., Giggles, cocktails and food, was at 2234 Wilton Dr. and Santos Italian, was at 2909 NE 6th Ave.

Other restaurants of that era still in operation include:

Stork’s Bakery and Café; opened by Jim Stork in the late 1990s.

Rosie’s Bar and Grill; originally opened in 2002 as a Hamburger Mary’s franchise, it broke away from the chain in 2006 and has grown into one of Wilton Manors' most iconic, gathering spots.

Tropics Grille; started as Al Hagen’s real estate office and also served as City Hall for a short time. In the 1940s. In the 19602, it was a drugstore with a lunch counter. It’s first iteration as a restaurant was as The Cookery Café, until 1991. The building was then used as a high energy dance bar known as Club Classics. Side by Side was a small dining area in the bar. Tropics was opened in an adjacent building opened by chef Nate DeLuca, and eventually became so popular that it took over the entire Club Classics space. It was later owned by Tony Dee and Charlie Mielke, then Jackson Padgett, Gary Hilolis, and Mark Taylor. Alex Meyer and Godfrey Thompson who owned the property, but not the business, took over the business in  2017. Paul Hugo and partner Danel Valero bought the bar soon afterwards. It is now operated by Henry Sims and Bashir Majid, who also own the Townhouse in New York.

Since then, Wilton Manors has become a dining destination. Among the cuisines available in the less than two-square-mile town are: Peruvian, Italian, Haitian, Thai, Japanese, French, Spanish, Chinese, Colombian, Cuban, Guatemalan, Filipino, Vietnamese, Argentinian, Greek, Classic American, Mexican, and fusions of almost any combination of the previously listed cuisines, as well as a deli, pub-fare, burgers and modern American. About the only thing you won’t find is chain fast-food. With the exception of ice cream and coffee, there are no chain restaurant in the town.

For a history of Wilton Manor’s LGBTQ bars, pick up a copy of my book, Last Call South Florida. Available at To The Moon or on Amazon.

OutSFL

Phone: 954-514-7095
Hours: Monday - Friday 9AM - 2PM
Editorial@OutSFL.com
Sales@OutSFL.com

Calendar@outsfl.com

Corrections: corrections@outsfl.com

PO Box 23817 • Oakland Park, FL 33307

Navigate

GOT A TIP?

Got a juicy lead or story idea? Let us know! You can also submit an anonymous news tip by clicking here.

GOT A TIP

   

Out South Florida

Help sustain independent LGBTQ journalism, community coverage, and local voices across South Florida.

donate button